Home > Joshiraku, Tonari no Kaibatsu-kun > Tonari no Kaibatsu-kun 1, Joshiraku 10

Tonari no Kaibatsu-kun 1, Joshiraku 10

Tonari no Kaibatsu-kun … What we got here is a girl who studies all the time meeting the class thug, realizes he’s not so bad after all, and the romance that happens after. This is such a tired story that the only time you see it in anime now is when they’re making fun of it, but this show adds a couple of twists.

Shizuku, the studious girl, isn’t a terribly pleasant person to be around. Since we’re watching the show mostly through her eyes we get a sense of the loneliness that this causes her, but also her mindset. They use a flashback of elementary school when the class rabbit dies. The rest of the class is crying, but she doesn’t. She doesn’t feel sad and frankly admits it. We don’t learn why she doesn’t, just that this is her mindset. So when the boy, Haru, decides she’s his friend she’s not sure how to handle it, especially when he confesses to her the second or third time they see each other. And that’s before the kiss he sneaks in the episode’s final minute.

The big problem with the first episode is Haru. He beats people up on the slightest provocation, snarls at everyone else, at one point abducts Chizuru threatening to rape her if she resists. Even if he was joking or didn’t quite understand the effect of these words (and I suspect both), it reveals an ugly mindset. To balance this we’d normally discover that he has a heart of gold or something, and the show actually plays with this cliché when he shows her the “stray dog” he rescued–a fully grown doberman with a studded collar, but it goes farther than that. Haru is a man-child who doesn’t understand how school works, or friends, or anything. When Shizuru (accidentally) talks him into returning to school he follows the rules he learned in manga and makes a complete fool of himself, and continues to beat people up.

Haru tries this ‘be nice to girls’ thing he’s read about.

I guess I can see the connection between them, and the show does a pretty good job, apart from Haru’s antics, of showing the relationship develop realistically. Shizuku reacts to him the way anyone would, by avoiding him as much as possible. There are some cliches–one subverted wonderfully when Haru’s “enemies” abduct Shizuru, though they’re embarrassed by it and treat her nicely. The worst is discovering that Haru is a genius, smarter than the studious Shizuru. While it helps to make her further confused about her feelings it also feels contrived, maybe because the first episode moves very quickly and it’s just tossed in there. I’m not sure where the show is going, but it looks pretty good and I liked watching Shizuku reacting to Haru. She has a temper, too, and isn’t afraid to let it out. Each scene has something memorable in it. If they can keep subverting the obvious things this might be okay, if Haru tones it down. Right now he’s too much.

No raw-watching Joshiraku this week. Episode 10’s best moments for me came in the Halloween section and the worry that American cultural imperialism will force them into observing things like Independence day and MLK day. Also the K-ON references. I’m not sure how the conversation got to a bomb in the room. The episode’s field trip to (Kabukichou) was interesting in that we learn that no Kabuki is performed there. The dental health section was a miss.

Advertisements
  1. Vincent
    October 2, 2012 at 4:03 pm

    As of now, Tonari no Kaibatsu-kun is just flat out unacceptable to me based on the bad subtext.

    Here is another blogger’s thoughts on the matter:

    http://gargarstegosaurus.wordpress.com/2012/10/02/tonari-no-kaibutsu-kun-at-a-glancestop-putting-rape-culture-in-all-my-shoujo-assholes/#more-4425

  2. October 2, 2012 at 10:46 pm

    Many thanks for the link.

    When that moment in the anime came up I thought “Whoa! You just don’t SAY shit like that!” but let it pass in the hope that the episode would redeem itself, but that post makes me think that I should have been harsher.

    I suppose you could treat the word as an absurdity, like Krauser II’s use of it on stage, but there he’s, well, on stage, performing. He hasn’t just pulled a girl into an alley and covered her mouth and used it as a threat. I could also explain it away by saying Haru doesn’t understand the word, that he picked it up from some manga (maybe even DMC!). The Moe Sucks pingback points out that he’s getting his social cues from the wrong places. It will be interesting to see just how this relationship develops. Shizuku doesn’t feel like the type of character that will fall into the shoujo-heroine stereotype. But for now the show is on probation for me.

    • Vincent
      October 10, 2012 at 9:47 am

      This response is really delayed, but I think that Haru does understand what the word rape means. I think it’s clear that he knows what sex is, as he thought that Shizuku wanted it in episode 1 when she stated that she was headed towards the gym. If he knows what sex is, there is a good chance that he also knows what rape is, although it’s not guaranteed.

  1. No trackbacks yet.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: